Comparing Open and Closed Rhinoplasty: Which Technique is Right for You?

Open Vs Closed Rhinoplasty Which Technique is Right for You

Choosing the right nose surgery depends on your goals. A skilled plastic surgeon can help you decide, ensuring it fits your needs. Open rhinoplasty enables surgeons to reshape your nose’s internal structures efficiently, preserving bone, cartilage, and tissue.

Open vs closed rhinoplasty: Overview

Open vs closed rhinoplasty Overview 2024

A nose job in Turkey improves nose size, shape, and facial balance, correcting issues caused by injury or aging. By giving patients the desired nose, it boosts self-esteem and quality of life. 

People choose rhinoplasty surgery for disproportionate noses or breathing problems. The procedure, lasting 1 to 3 hours under local or general anesthesia, might require a short hospital stay for complex cases. 

Swelling lasts several months post-surgery, temporarily changing the nose’s appearance until fully healed.

HayatMed Clinic, located in Istanbul/Turkey, is highly experienced in performing plastic surgery. Based on patients’ evaluations, we offer satisfactory results at an affordable cost. We offer a free consultation on WhatsApp.

Open rhinoplasty vs closed rhinoplasty: Definition

These 2 methods of the procedure differ in terms of definition, the way the operation is conducted, and many other things. The difference in definition is as follows:

Open Rhinoplasty

Enhancing facial harmony by reshaping the nose, Open Rhinoplasty corrects issues like bumps, width, length, and symmetry while improving breathing.

It involves an incision across the columella, providing clear visibility for precise reshaping. Initially, a visible scar may appear, which fades over time. Prioritize skill and experience when selecting a surgeon for optimal results and recovery.

Closed nose job

Closed nose job Open Rhinoplasty Vs Closed Rhinoplasty

Closed rhinoplasty minimizes scarring by using small incisions inside the nostrils. A board-certified surgeon carefully reshapes the nostrils, bridge, and tip of the nose for a better look.

Typically lasting 1.5-3 hours with IV sedation, this procedure is suitable for minor adjustments like reducing a nasal hump or fixing an unbalanced tip.

During a consultation, a skilled surgeon will assess its suitability. Given the complexity of nose surgery, selecting an experienced surgeon is crucial to avoid poor aesthetic results or harm to nasal function.

Related: Asian Bulbous Nose Rhinoplasty

HayatMed Clinic, located in Istanbul/Turkey, is highly experienced in performing plastic surgery. Based on patients’ evaluations, we offer satisfactory results at an affordable cost. We offer a free consultation on WhatsApp.

Comparing Open and Closed Rhinoplasty

Amount of Change:

  • Open nose job: Recommended for detailed adjustments, providing better visibility of the nose structure.
  • Closed Rhinoplasty: Suitable for minor adjustments, still capable of making significant changes without cutting into the nose skin.

Recovery:

  • Open Rhinoplasty: Recovery may take longer due to the more invasive nature of the procedure.
  • Closed nose surgery: Typically results in a quicker recovery due to not cutting into the nose skin.

Scarring:

  • An open nose job involves an incision across the columella, which may initially result in visible scarring, though it fades over time.
  • Closed Rhinoplasty: Leaves just one small scar between the nostrils, which usually fades with time, resulting in more natural-looking results.

Related: Wide Nose Ethnic Rhinoplasty

Plastic Surgeries in Turkey At Best Prices

Our packages cover medical fees, hospital stays, airport transfers, and personal host services for a seamless experience.

Eligibility for Open and Closed Rhinoplasty

Eligibility for Open and Closed Rhinoplasty

Open Rhinoplasty:

  • Candidates:
  1. Patients with significant nasal issues or specific structural concerns.
  2. Those willing to accept visible scarring and longer recovery times.
  3. Individuals who are seeking precise alterations to various areas of the nose.

Closed Rhinoplasty:

  • Candidates:
  1. Patients requiring minor adjustments or enhancements.
  2. Individuals are desiring minimal scarring and shorter recovery periods.
  3. Those with less extensive nasal structural concerns or seeking natural-looking results without prominent scarring.

Related: Revision Rhinoplasty Surgery

Pros and Cons of Each Technique

Open Rhinoplasty:

Open Rhinoplasty Closed Rhinoplasty Vs Open Rhinoplasty

Pros:

  • Better visibility and access for surgeons
  • Precise adjustments are possible on the bridge, nostrils, tip, and other areas of the nose.
  • Suitable for patients with significant nasal changes and specific structural concerns

Cons:

  • More invasive, leading to longer procedures and recovery times
  • Swelling or bruising can last for weeks or months
  • Visible scarring on the columella

Related: Best Rhinoplasty Surgeon in Turkey

Closed nose job:

Pros:

  • Minimized scarring due to small incisions inside the nostrils
  • Less invasive, typically resulting in shorter procedures and recovery times
  • Suitable for minor adjustments like reducing a nasal hump or fixing an unbalanced tip

Cons:

  • Limited visibility and access for surgeons
  • Less precise adjustments compared to open nose surgery
  • It may not be suitable for patients with significant nasal changes or specific structural concerns.

Closed Rhinoplasty Vs Open Rhinoplasty: Cost

Closed Rhinoplasty Vs Open Rhinoplasty Cost

In the US, an open-nose job costs typically between $5,000 and $15,000. In the UK, it ranges from £4,000 to £7,000, but prices can vary depending on the patient.

Factors affecting the cost include:

  • Procedure complexity
  • Surgeon’s experience
  • Fees for surgery and anesthesia

Insurance might help pay for surgery if it’s needed for functional reasons, like fixing a deviated septum.

Closed rhinoplasty generally costs between $4,000 to $10,000 or more in The US and £6,000 to £9,000 in the UK, depending on:

  • Procedure complexity
  • Surgeon’s expertise
  • Additional expenses

Insurance usually offers limited coverage for cosmetic procedures, but it may help for medical reasons like breathing difficulties.

Related: Ultrasonic Nose Job Price

open vs. closed nose surgery Cost in Turkey

In Turkey, the average cost for open rhinoplasty ranges from $5,100 to $7,200. At Hayatmed Clinic, an open nose job costs 2900 euros, while a closed rhinoplasty costs 3200 euros. 

These prices include all expenses, such as hotel, transportation, and medication. Hayatmed Clinic promises the best results for rhinoplasty in Turkey.

Plastic Surgeries in Turkey At Best Prices

Our packages cover medical fees, hospital stays, airport transfers, and personal host services for a seamless experience.

Open Vs. Closed Nose Surgery: Recovery

Open Vs. Closed Nose Surgery Recovery

Open Nose Surgery Recovery:

  • Swelling and bruising: This is more noticeable at first due to extensive surgery.
  • Healing Time: Longer than closed surgery due to more tissue trauma.
  • Visible Scar: Small scar on columella that fades over time.
  • Activity Restrictions: Longer avoidance of strenuous activities.

Closed Nose Surgery Recovery:

  • Minimal Swelling and Bruising: Less noticeable as incisions are inside nostrils.
  • Faster Healing: Closed rhinoplasty Recovery time is shorter due to fewer invasive procedures.
  • No Visible Scarring: Incisions are hidden inside nostrils, and there are no external scars.
  • Fewer Activity Restrictions: Normal activities resume sooner.

Overall Comparison:

  • Swelling and Bruising: Less with closed surgery.
  • Healing Time: Faster with closed surgery.
  • Scarring: Small scar with open surgery, none with closed.
  • Activity Restrictions: Fewer after closed surgery.

In short, closed nose surgery often means quicker, smoother recovery with less swelling, bruising, and scarring compared to open surgery.

Rhinoplasty Open Vs Closed: Pain and Scar

Open nose surgery:

  • Pain: Some patients experience moderate discomfort, which is managed with pain medication.
  • Scar: A small scar is visible on the columella, the tissue between the nostrils, but it usually fades over time.

Closed Rhinoplasty:

  • Pain: Generally, patients experience less discomfort compared to open rhinoplasty, with pain easily managed with medication.
  • Scar: No visible external scarring as incisions are made inside the nostrils.

In summary, while both types of nose surgery may involve some discomfort, closed rhinoplasty typically results in less pain and no visible external scarring compared to open rhinoplasty.

What changes can a surgeon make during an open or closed nose surgery?

What changes can a surgeon make during an open or closed nose surgery

In open rhinoplasty:

  • Improved view: Surgeons see nasal structures directly through an incision on the columella.
  • Easier corrections: Better access to complex areas like the nasal tip allows for detailed adjustments.
  • Greater precision: Surgeons can manipulate nasal structures more precisely, achieving desired outcomes effectively.

In closed nose job:

  • Less invasive: Incisions inside nostrils mean no external scars.
  • Quicker recovery: Reduced swelling and bruising lead to faster healing.
  • Restricted access: Working through small nostril incisions may limit modifications, especially for complex cases.

In short, an open-nose job allows for better visibility and access to complex corrections. However, it may result in a visible scar on the columella.

Closed rhinoplasty is less invasive, avoids external scarring, and typically results in a faster recovery. However, it may limit access to certain nasal structures for modifications.

Factors to Consider When Choosing Between Open and Closed Rhinoplasty

Factors to Consider When Choosing Between Open and Closed Nose Surgery:

  • Skilled Plastic Surgeon: Look for a surgeon who understands both aesthetics and function of the nose.
  • Communication: Discuss your goals with your surgeon to determine the most suitable technique for you.
  • Surgeon’s Experience: Find a surgeon with proven results in the technique you prefer.
  • Complications: Consider potential complications such as visible scarring and discuss them with your surgeon.
  • Double Board Certification: Opt for a surgeon with double-board certification, indicating they meet high standards in plastic surgery.
  • Personal Preferences: Consider your tolerance for visible scarring, recovery time, and other factors that may influence your choice.

Making an Informed Decision

Making an Informed Decision Open Rhinoplasty Vs Closed

Making an Informed Decision:

  • Understand the Differences: Patients should grasp the variances between open and closed rhinoplasty surgery techniques.
  • Patient-Surgeon Collaboration: Collaborate with your surgeon to select the best approach aligned with your goals and requirements.
  • Open nose job: Offers improved visibility and access for major modifications or precise adjustments to the nose.
  • Closed Rhinoplasty: Results in less visible scarring but may not be ideal for extensive structural changes to the nose.

Case Studies and Patient Experiences

Your surgeon is crucial for successful rhinoplasty, whether you choose open or closed surgery. With experience, they know which techniques work best.

Both methods can achieve beautiful results, but there is limited data on patient satisfaction and outcomes. A nose job is complex, and recovery may take time.

To speed it up, sleep with your head elevated, use cold compresses, and take pain medication as needed.

Open Vs. Closed Rhinoplasty FAQs

Closed and open rhinoplasty each have advantages. Closed rhinoplasty is preferred for minor changes with smaller incisions, while open rhinoplasty allows for better visibility for the surgeon.

A drawback of closed rhinoplasty is limited surgical access. Incisions inside the nostrils can make precise adjustments that are more challenging than open rhinoplasty, especially for complex cases.

Open rhinoplasty tends to be pricier than closed. This is due to longer surgery times, specialized instruments, and more extensive incisions.

Not everyone is suitable for both closed and open rhinoplasty. Suitability depends on factors like nasal anatomy, desired changes, and the surgeon’s expertise.

Closed rhinoplasty often heals faster initially due to less tissue trauma and smaller incisions. However, overall healing time varies based on individual factors and the extent of the procedure.

Both closed and open rhinoplasty can be safe when performed by experienced surgeons. Safety depends on the surgeon’s expertise, adherence to safety protocols, and the patient’s overall health.

Yes, breathing should not be significantly affected after closed rhinoplasty. Improving nasal function is usually a goal, and surgeons take care to maintain or enhance the nasal airway during the procedure for post-operative comfort.

About the author

Picture of Zeyna Aslan
Zeyna Aslan

Zeyna Aslan, a medical writer at Hayatmed Clinic, brings 13 years of experience in the field. She excels in creating clear, engaging content that educates and informs. Zeyna's expertise spans across plastic surgery and hair transplant procedures. Her work helps potential patients understand their options and make informed decisions. At Hayatmed Clinic, Zeyna's dedication to quality content plays a vital role in converting visitors into satisfied patients. see profile on linkedin

Linkedin

Share the Article

Facebook
Twitter
Reddit
LinkedIn
Pinterest
WhatsApp
Call us WhatsApp